Child Custody Disputes

The custody of minor children is often the most contested issue in a divorce or separation. At Millar Legal, a trusted child custody attorney in Utah, we understand how important your children are to you. You want what is best for your children, and so do we.

A child benefits from healthy relationships with both parents. Years of experience have taught us that resolving custody disputes in a collaborative manner decreases the stress put on the child and lays the groundwork for parents to work together in the future. At Millar Legal, we are skilled in mediation, which can be a highly effective arena for resolving custody disputes amicably.

However, because children are particularly vulnerable, we must act quickly when one parent’s neglect or misconduct puts a child at risk. Utah custody laws are subjective and place absolute priority on the best interests of the children. Convincing a court of where a child’s best interests lie requires a skilled advocate with a mastery of the facts and your position. Ultimately, the court’s version of what is best for the children may differ from what either parent believes is best.

Child looking sad while parents argue in background at home

Legal vs. Physical Custody

Utah law differentiates between two main types of custody: legal and physical.

Legal Custody is the right and responsibility to make major decisions regarding the child’s life, such as medical care, religious upbringing, and education.

  • Joint Legal Custody: Parents share the right and responsibility to make these major decisions together. In most Utah cases, parents are awarded joint legal custody unless there is a compelling reason not to.
  • Sole Legal Custody: One parent is granted the exclusive right to make major decisions for the child.

Physical Custody refers to where the children will reside and how much time they will spend with each parent.

  • Sole Physical Custody (Primary Physical Custody): One parent has the child for more than 70% of the overnights during the year, with routine parent-time (visitation) awarded to the other parent. This is a common arrangement.
  • Joint Physical Custody: The child stays with each parent overnight for more than 30% of the year. This requires significant cooperation between parents.
  • Split Custody: A rare arrangement applicable only when there are at least two children, and each parent is awarded primary physical custody of at least one child.

Generally, the parent who cares for the child the majority of the time will receive child support from the other parent.

Trusted Support

in High Conflict Cases

How Utah Courts Decide Custody

When a custody dispute goes to court, the judge’s primary consideration is always the “best interest of the child.” According to the Utah Code, courts consider numerous factors to determine this, including:

W

The past conduct and demonstrated moral standards of each parent.

W

Which parent is most likely to act in the best interest of the child going forward, including encouraging frequent and continuing contact with the noncustodial parent.

W

The quality and depth of the relationship between the parent and the child.

W

Each parent’s role in raising the child before the divorce or separation.

W

Each parent’s current situation and ability to nurture the child financially, emotionally, and physically.

W

The preference of the child, provided the court determines the child is of sufficient age and capacity to reason. As of 2013, the preference of a child 14 years old or older is given added weight, though it is never the sole controlling factor.

W

Importantly, Utah law dictates that no preference may be given to either the mother or the father based on gender alone.

Custody Evaluations

In highly contested cases where the best interest of the child is difficult to determine based on testimony alone, the court may order, or the parties may agree to, a custody evaluation. A custody evaluation is a formal, in-depth assessment conducted by a trained, neutral mental health professional. The evaluator’s role is to investigate the family dynamics, interview parents and children, and sometimes review medical or school records to assist the court in determining the most appropriate custody arrangement. To learn more about this process, read our detailed guide on what to expect in a Utah Custody Evaluation.

Serving Salt Lake City and Utah Families

If you are preparing for a custody battle, it is crucial to become as active and involved as possible in the lives of your children and carefully document that involvement. Throughout the legal process, remember that the court evaluates your behavior entirely, both inside and outside the courtroom. Irrational or aggressive behavior will negatively impact your case.

Navigating a custody dispute requires steady guidance. By hiring a dedicated child custody attorney in Salt Lake City, you give yourself the best opportunity to convince the court that your proposed custody arrangement truly serves the best interests of your children.

Schedule a Consultation

Let us be your advocate through this challenging process. We can help you protect what is most important to you and avoid pitfalls that can cause years of pain and regret. Contact Millar Legal today to schedule a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a child custody dispute take to resolve in Utah?

The timeline varies drastically. If parents can reach an agreement through mediation, it can be resolved relatively quickly. If the case requires a full trial or a custody evaluation, it can take many months or even over a year.

Can a child choose which parent to live with in Utah?

A child cannot solely make the decision. While a judge may consider the desires of a child, especially if they are 14 or older and possess sufficient maturity, the child’s preference is only one of many factors considered in the “best interest” analysis.

Does a mother always get primary custody?

No. Utah law explicitly states that no custody preference can be given based on the parent’s gender. The court’s decision is based entirely on an evaluation of the best interests of the child.

What is a Parent-Time Schedule?

Parent-time (often called visitation in other states) refers to the specific schedule detailing when the non-custodial parent (or the parent with less time in a joint arrangement) will spend time with the child. Utah has statutory minimum guidelines, but parents can agree to custom schedules.

Let’s Work Together